Skip to main content
Patrice
Try the demo
Free comparison

PER or PEA: what is left at retirement?

For the same pre-tax savings effort, what each French wrapper leaves you at the end — and the retirement tax bracket where one catches up with the other. Your figures never leave your browser.

Your effort and your tax

The income you set aside each year — paid in full into the PER, net of tax into the PEA

The compounding period

The same for both — this compares the wrappers, not the investments

The rate of the last bracket of your French income tax — on your tax notice

Often lower: that is the PER's lever

Your figures are never sent: the calculation runs on your device. Only an anonymous audience measure (page view, click) is recorded, without any figure.

Enter a savings effort and a duration to compare.

The guide

PER or PEA: how the choice is made

The PER retirement plan deducts your contributions from taxable income: at a 30% marginal rate, €5,000 paid in costs you €3,500. In exchange, at exit, those contributions are taxed at the scale and the gains at the 30% flat tax. The capital is locked until retirement, except for buying a main home and life accidents.

The PEA share plan deducts nothing: you pay in what is left after tax. But after five years, gains bear only 17.2% social levies, and the money stays available. Two opposite logics — one defers tax, the other pays it now and never sees it again.

What decides is your marginal rate in retirement against today's. The more it falls, the more the PER wins. And against intuition, the PER often keeps the edge even at an equal bracket: it compounded the gross, the PEA the net. The calculator gives the exact break-even for your figures.

The four steps of the comparison

  1. Fix the same pre-tax effort

    The only honest comparison. Into the PER, the whole effort goes, since it is deducted. Into the PEA, only the after-tax amount: effort × (1 − bracket).

  2. Compound at the same return

    Both wrappers can hold the same funds; what differs is the tax wrapper, not the investment. The calculator applies the same rate to both.

  3. Tax the PER exit

    Deducted contributions go through the retirement scale, without the 10% pension allowance; gains at the 30% flat tax. Exiting in several instalments avoids climbing a bracket.

  4. Tax the PEA exit

    After five years, only 17.2% social levies on gains. Nothing on contributions, already taxed at entry.

It is not one or the other: many do both, the PER up to the deduction ceiling when the bracket is high, the PEA for the rest and for liquidity. What matters is revisiting it every year — bracket, ceilings, value — rather than deciding once.

The choice is worth revisiting every year, with your real wrappers

Your bracket changes, your ceilings too. Patrice tracks your PER, your PEA and your life insurance side by side, with their contributions and value — and projects what they become at retirement. The account is free; the demo shows the app with sample data.

Create my free accountSee the demo

Further reading

The French PER: what the deduction really earns youtaxation
Intermediate

The French PER: what the deduction really earns you

The PER deducts contributions from French taxable income, but the tax returns on withdrawal. What each bracket actually gains, and when the lock-up isn't worth it.

taxation9 min read
PEA Tax After 5 Years: How French Social Contributions Actually Worktaxation
Intermediate

PEA Tax After 5 Years: How French Social Contributions Actually Work

What changes at the 5-year mark, why 17.2% remains, how the CSG/CRDS/social levy breakdown works, and the small habits that make the most of the wrapper.

taxation9 min read

Frequently asked questions

Because it compounds the gross amount for the whole period, where the PEA compounds only the after-tax amount. Over twenty years at 4%, that base gap outweighs the heavier taxation of gains at exit. The break-even is often a few points above the entry bracket.

10% of the previous year's professional income, within an annual ceiling, with carry-forward of the unused ceilings of the three previous years. The calculator does not check it: beyond it, contributions are no longer deducted and lose their point.

The annuity is taxed like a pension, with the 10% allowance, and partly to social levies. That is a different calculation, depending on life expectancy and the contract's conversion rate. This comparison only covers the lump-sum exit.

After five years, yes: free withdrawals, without closing. Before five years, a withdrawal closes the plan and gains are taxed at the 30% flat tax. The PER stays locked until retirement outside the release cases.

No. The calculation runs in your browser and your figures disappear when you close the tab. We only measure, anonymously, that the page was viewed and a calculation was made — never the amounts.